Wednesday, February 29, 2012

An eye-opener from far away



N.C. State University looked far from home when it picked the architect for its new library, named for former Gov. Jim Hunt.

A few twinges of jealousy struck me, I have to admit, during a presentation by Craig Dykers of Snohetta, a firm founded in Oslo, Norway, in 1989. (A quick apology: The first vowel in the firm's name should be that O-with-a-slash that their language uses but ours doesn't. As far as anyone can tell me, my keyboard can't get it from blogger.com. Sorry, Norway.)

Dykers devoted a hefty portion of his 90 minutes or so to the opera house his firm designed in its hometown. As you can see from the photo above (by Christopher Hagelund from www.snoarc.no) it sits right on the city's waterfront.

Its plaza, rather than being hemmed in by a railing, slants right down to the water. If you click on the photo for a larger version, you'll see this: After the plaza rises alongside the theater and meets the roof line, it then turns and covers the roof. So a visitor can start at the water, standing toe-to-toe with the swans, and walk up and around to the promontory atop the building, where there's a commanding view of the harbor. Magnificent. People who don't care what's happening onstage go to sight-see or sunbathe.

The plaza is roomy enough to accommodate alfresco audiences for video relays from inside the theater. The indoor audiences can mingle in lobbies that are airy, spacious and free-flowing.

The building itself wasn't what set off my pangs, though, so much as what it represented. It showed what designers can come up with when they -- and their employers -- imagine a theater that's more than just a box. That's how Sydney, Australia, created the opera house that's the city's emblem around the world.

Charlotte's mind evidently doesn't work that way. The Blumenthal Performing Arts Center has almost no visual profile at all -- just a glorified awning on Tryon Street, basically. The newer Knight Theater collides with the rear of the Bechtler Museum of Modern Art.

The Blumenthal center was built before my time in Charlotte, so I didn't see its creation. But I was on hand during the genesis of the Knight Theater and the rest of the South Tryon cultural center. During those months and months of public meetings, the discussions had one focus: making sure that the buildings used up no more money or land than necessary. That's reasonable enough, as far as it goes. But creativity with the buildings' appearance -- even as a road to saving money -- didn't figure in.

It's always possible to learn, though. There no doubt are years ahead of us before Charlotte builds any more cultural facilities. That leaves time to drag more of Charlotte's leaders, especially those with sway over the arts, to presentations like the one by the architect from Oslo. Maybe their minds -- and eyes -- would open.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

horrible!

JennAMom said...

What's horrible exactly? The newly designed library or the opera house? I think they're both cool. Definitely better than the boring brick box that's the DH Hill library. (That being said, if I were an NC State architecture grad I'd be pretty offended they picked someone from Norway to design this.)

Archiguy said...

Jenn - agree totally. NC State has a wealth of alumni talent to choose from. If not there, then at least stay in the U.S., preferably here in NC. We have imaginative architects here, believe it or not.

That's what's "horrible" about this story.

Nathan Forrest said...

Doesn't NC State have an architecture school?

Anonymous said...

I have to say I'm confused as to what the basis of this article was. Was it about the new library at NC State or Snohetta's experience? The tagline suggests it's about NC State. If so a image of the library in the blog would have been nice as it is a dramatic design.

As for going out of State, as many have commented on, he doesn't mention that Snohetta is the "design" architect and not the "lead" & "production" architect. That firm is Pearce Brinkley Cease + Lee out of Raleigh & Asheville. (BTW - 7 of the 9 principals are graduates of NC State)

Anonymous said...

So Steven,

You've certainly lived long enough to know that many of Charlotte's civic endeavors are cobbled together with a little money, a lot of arm-twisting and a good deal of compromise. I'm surprised it ever got built.

The interior (Belk Theater) is not unlike Davies Hall in San Francisco, so maybe the hall itself is sufficiently grand and acoustically sound to merit our gratitude without losing our objectivity.

The Oslo hall is gorgeous.

Anonymous said...

Norway - Wouldn't ice be a minor problem, or is that not a slippery slope?